Broadway has long been the beating heart of theatrical innovation, blending storytelling, music, and spectacle to create timeless cultural phenomena. From record-breaking musicals to groundbreaking dramas, these shows have redefined entertainment, drawing millions of fans and generating billions in revenue. But what makes a Broadway show truly legendary? Is it longevity, critical acclaim, or sheer box-office dominance?
This article ranks the top 10 Broadway shows of all time, balancing fan adoration, critic reviews, financial success, and historical impact. Whether you’re a theater enthusiast or a casual viewer, this list celebrates the productions that have left an indelible mark on the Great White Way.
Which is the Best Broadway Show of All Time?
The title of “best” Broadway show sparks passionate debate.
For some, The Phantom of the Opera—with its 13,981 performances and 35-year run—epitomizes endurance and artistry. Others argue that The Lion King, a visual and musical marvel grossing over $2.06 billion, represents the pinnacle of creativity and commercial success.
Meanwhile, modern masterpieces like Hamilton have reshaped Broadway’s landscape with genre-blending storytelling. While no single metric defines greatness, this list weighs rankings, revenue, cultural influence, and audience ratings to crown Broadway’s most iconic productions.
Top 10 Broadway Shows of All Time (Ranked by Critics & Fans)
Here is a table of the top 10 Broadway shows of all time (ranked according to critics and fan ratings):
| Rank | Show Name | Premiere Date | Performances | Gross Revenue | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | The Lion King | November 13, 1997 | 10,804 | $2.06 billion | Active |
| 2 | Wicked | October 30, 2003 | 8,338 | $1.73 billion | Active |
| 3 | The Phantom of the Opera | January 26, 1988 | 13,981 | $1.36 billion | Ended (2023) |
| 4 | Chicago (1996 revival) | November 14, 1996 | 11,177 | $807.6 million | Active |
| 5 | Hamilton | August 6, 2015 | 3,405 | $1.03 billion | Active |
| 6 | The Book of Mormon | March 24, 2011 | 5,191 | $835.1 million | Active |
| 7 | Cats | October 7, 1982 | 7,485 | $453.6 million | Ended (2000) |
| 8 | Les Misérables | March 12, 1987 | 6,680 | $514.8 million | Ended (2003) |
| 9 | Mamma Mia! | October 18, 2001 | 5,758 | $624.4 million | Ended (2015) |
| 10 | Aladdin | March 20, 2014 | 3,965 | $703.9 million | Active |
Let’s know more about these shows in more detail:
1. The Lion King
Fan Rating: 4.8/5
Adapted from Disney’s animated classic, The Lion King revolutionized Broadway with Julie Taymor’s visionary puppetry and African-inspired choreography. Since 1997, it has enchanted over 110 million viewers, becoming the highest-grossing Broadway show ever.
Its iconic soundtrack, including “Circle of Life” and “Can You Feel the Love Tonight,” merges Elton John’s melodies with Lebo M’s African vocals. The show’s $2.06 billion revenue reflects its universal appeal, while its environmental themes resonate across generations. Still running at the Minskoff Theatre, it’s a must-see for its artistry and emotional depth.
2. Wicked
Fan Rating: 4.7/5
This prequel to The Wizard of Oz reimagines the Wicked Witch of the West as a misunderstood heroine. With Stephen Schwartz’s soaring score (“Defying Gravity”) and a narrative celebrating individuality, Wicked has grossed $1.73 billion since 2003.
Its themes of friendship and societal prejudice strike a chord, while Idina Menzel and Kristin Chenoweth’s original performances remain legendary. A staple at the Gershwin Theatre, it continues to sell out nightly, proving that “good” and “wicked” are often a matter of perspective.
3. The Phantom of the Opera
Fan Rating: 4.9/5
Andrew Lloyd Webber’s gothic masterpiece held Broadway captive for 35 years before closing in 2023. With its chandelier crash, operatic arias (“The Music of the Night”), and tragic romance, Phantom became synonymous with Broadway grandeur. It’s 13,981 performances and $1.36 billion in revenue set unmatched records.
Though its run has ended, revivals and global tours ensure the Phantom’s legacy lives on.
4. Chicago (1996 Revival)
Fan Rating: 4.5/5
The revival of this jazz-age satire surpassed its 1975 original, becoming Broadway’s longest-running revival. Bob Fosse’s razor-sharp choreography and a score featuring “All That Jazz” dissect fame and corruption with dark humor.
Its minimalist staging and enduring relevance—especially in today’s true-crime-obsessed culture—have fueled its 11,000+ performances. Still playing at the Ambassador Theatre, Chicago proves that “razzle-dazzle” never goes out of style.
5. Hamilton
Fan Rating: 4.9/5
Lin-Manuel Miranda’s hip-hop biography of Alexander Hamilton redefined Broadway for the 21st century.
With its diverse cast and Pulitzer-winning script, Hamilton tackles immigration, legacy, and democracy through rapid-fire lyrics (“My Shot”) and genre fusion. Grossing $1.03 billion by 2023, it’s a cultural touchstone that democratized theater, attracting A-list celebrities and Gen Z fans alike.
6. The Book of Mormon
Fan Rating: 4.6/5
This irreverent satire by South Park creators Trey Parker and Matt Stone follows Mormon missionaries in Uganda. Its blend of slapstick humor and catchy tunes (“Hello!”) earned nine Tonys and $835 million since 2011.
While controversial, its critique of dogma and colonialism resonates, selling out the Eugene O’Neill Theatre nightly.
7. Cats
Fan Rating: 4.3/5
Andrew Lloyd Webber’s feline fantasy dominated the 1980s with its groundbreaking makeup and Jellicle Ball spectacle.
Though criticized for its thin plot, “Memory” became an anthem, and its 7,485-performance run set early records. The 2019 film adaptation flopped, but the original remains a nostalgic favorite.
8. Les Misérables
Fan Rating: 4.7/5
Victor Hugo’s epic of revolution and redemption found new life in Claude-Michel Schönberg’s stirring score (“I Dreamed a Dream”).
The barricade set and 6,680 performances made it a 1980s staple. Though the original closed in 2003, its 2014 revival and global tours affirm its timeless power.
9. Mamma Mia!
Fan Rating: 4.4/5
This ABBA-fueled romp on a Greek island launched the “jukebox musical” craze. With feel-good hits like “Dancing Queen,” it ran for 14 years and grossed $624 million.
A crowd-pleaser, it’s spawned sequels and tribute bands, proving pop nostalgia sells.
10. Aladdin
Fan Rating: 4.5/5
Disney’s magic carpet ride dazzles with flying carpets, genies, and Alan Menken’s Oscar-winning songs (“A Whole New World”). Since 2014, it’s $704 million gross and 3,965 shows cement it as a family favorite.
A testament to Disney’s Broadway reign, it’s second only to The Lion King.
Read Next:
Conclusion: The Lion King and Wicked Are The Best Broadway Shows of All Time
From The Lion King’s primal rhythms to Hamilton’s revolutionary beats, these shows exemplify Broadway’s power to innovate and inspire. While revenue and longevity offer one measure of success, their true legacy lies in their cultural imprint—whether redefining genres, sparking social dialogue, or simply bringing joy to millions.
As new productions emerge, these titans remind us that Broadway’s magic endures when artistry meets audacity. So grab a ticket, settle into the red velvet seats, and let the curtain rise on stories that transcend time.
